The Penderwicks
The Penderwicks: A Summer Tale of Four Sisters, Two Rabbits, and a Very Interesting Boy by Jeanne Birdsall
This one came recommended to me by my mum and one of her co-workers, and I thought it would be a good read to follow up One Hundred Years of Solitude. And it was! It’s a light, sweet, children’s book about a family of four sisters and their father who go on a family vacation. They’ve rented a cottage, sight unseen, and what they don’t realize is that the cottage is situated on the grand and beautiful estate Arundel. The book tells of the adventures the sisters have on their summer holiday.
If I didn’t know that the book was written in 2005, I might have thought that it was a lost work of Edith Nesbit or Edgar Eager, (whose books I loved as a child) without the magic. Overall, I found that it was a lovely book!
The Penderwicks on Gardam Street by Jeanne Birdsall
The sequel to The Penderwicks. I liked it because I missed the characters from the first book but overall I preferred the first book. The sequel just didn’t have the same element of old-fashioned charm. However, Birdsall’s characters are consistent from the first book to the second, so it was still an enjoyable read.
One Hundred Years of Solitude
One Hundred Years of Solitude by Gabriel García Márquez
Translated from the Spanish by Gregory Rabassa
I can safely say that I have never read anything like this book before. I thought that I understood the genre of magic realism prior to reading this, but it turns out that wasn’t quite true. Had I the task of explaining the traits of the genre to someone who hadn’t heard of it before, I should rather hand them a copy of this book.
To summarize the story would actually be quite simple. The book tells the of the Buendía family’s history in the town of Macondo. But to summarize the uniqueness and appeal of this book is much harder.
Is it possible to explain something that you can’t put into words? I feel that the only way that I can convey my appreciation for the book is by lifting three images from the book itself that have made a distinct impression on my memory.
1. Before them, surrounded by ferns and palm trees, white and powdery in the silent morning light, was an enormous Spanish galleon. Tilted slightly to the starboard, it had hanging from its intact masts the dirty rags of its sails in the midst of its rigging, which was adorned with orchids. The hull, covered with an armor of petrified barnacles and soft moss, was firmly fastened into a surface of stones. The whole structure seemed to occupy its own space, one of solitude and oblivion, protected from the vices of time and the habits of the birds. Inside, where the expeditionaries explored with careful intent, there was nothing but a thick forest of flowers. (11-12)
2. A short time later, when the carpenter was taking measurements for the coffin, through the window they saw a light rain of tiny yellow flowers falling. They fell on the town all through the night in a silent storm, and they covered the roof and blocked the doors and smothered the animals who slept outdoors. So many flowers fell from the sky that in the morning the streets were carpeted with a compact cushion and they had to clear them away with shovels and rakes so the funeral procession could pass by. (140)
3. The yellow butterflies would invade the house at dusk. (I would expand on this, but I don’t want to give away important plot points!)
In addition to these kinds of images that run throughout the narrative, I feel that another unique aspect of this book is its structure. At one point in the story, the character Ursula “shudder[s] with the evidence that time was not passing, as she had just admitted, but that it was turning in a circle” (335). This statement gives a good idea of the overall narrative style. García Márquz often reveals the outcome of a situation long before the reader is aware of the circumstances or relevance of this disclosure, and it often isn’t until much later that the story circles around to explain these circumstances. In this way, the novel gives the impression of moving linearly through the family history of the Buendía family while simultaneously drifting backwards and forwards through time.
I definitely recommend this one.
Eleanor Rigby
Eleanor Rigby by Douglas Coupland
This entry will be proof that I should really write these up as soon as I’ve finished a book, and not a month later after I’ve already returned the book to its owner and forgotten whatever it was that I intended to write about it. (Unfortunately both of these things have happened, and the book does not seem to have made a lasting impression on my memory, even though it really only has been a few weeks since I read it!)
I think that this is probably my favourite of the books by Coupland that I have read so far. I still haven’t entirely made up my mind about how I feel about his writing, even though I’ve now read four or five of his books. I keep reading them because they come so highly recommended to me, and because I feel so ambivalent about the previous ones I’ve read. (This is precisely how I felt about Margaret Atwood until I read Alias Grace.) It’s not that I didn’t enjoy reading Eleanor Rigby but I don’t think that Coupland is my kind of writer.
I can’t quite put my finger on what it is about his books that I don’t like. I think that a large part of it has to do with his pessimistic attitude toward modern society that I don’t entirely agree with. I do believe that our society has its problems, but instead of feeling motivated to fix things after finishing his books, I just have an overall feeling of negativity. I found that Eleanor Rigby was actually better for that than some of his other books.
I realize that this entry makes it sound like I really didn’t enjoy Eleanor Rigby, which isn’t true. It’s more that it didn’t stay with me at all, and now my memory of it is vague and clouded, but I have no intention of revisiting it to clarify my feelings toward it.
The Third Angel
The Third Angel by Alice Hoffman
I’ve had Alice Hoffman in the back of my mind as an author I wanted to check out ever since I saw the movie Practical Magic, which is based on her novel of the same name. I actually meant to start out with Practical Magic, because I just love that story, but I guess it just became one of those many books that I mean to read and then never quite get around to reading. Mum had an advance reading copy of The Third Angel lying around the house, so I borrowed it from her at her recommendation.
The novel tells the stories of three women all in love with men who are somehow wrong for them. As the book unfolds, it becomes apparent that these women are interconnected in surprising ways. Their individual stories build on each other and form the pieces of another, larger story that involves all of them. The book works backwards in time, beginning with Maddy Heller’s experiences when she stays at the Lion Park Hotel for her sister’s wedding in 1999. The novel then deals with a significant event in Frieda Lewis’s life when she worked as a chambermaid in the Lion Park Hotel in London in the mid ’60s. Finally, the book takes us back to twelve-year-old Lucy Green’s trip to the Lion Park Hotel in 1952, where she witnesses a tragedy that will influence the lives of both Maddy and Frieda when they come to the hotel.
I had some trouble getting into the novel at first, mostly because I wasn’t all that engaged with Maddy’s story. I wasn’t sure what to make of the elements of magic and the supernatural events that were running through the story, either, because at the outset the book appears to be simply realistic fiction. Once I got to Frieda’s section of the book, I got really immersed in the story, and accepted the magical elements without trying to figure out their exact role in the story. I actually grew to really enjoy the magical element of her work. Furthermore, I loved that there was a fairy tale called The Heron’s Wife that figured in some important way in each story. Overall, I found that the three individual stories fit together extremely well, with each story leaving a trail of clues for the subsequent tale.
Everything was yellow in the park. When it rained, leaves came swirling down. When it was sunny everything looked golden. Frieda Lewis was nineteen and had been working for four months at the Lion Park Hotel in Knightsbridge. Her favourite rooms to clean were teh ones on the seventh floor. From there, she could look out the windows in the back and see the little courtyard park with its stone lion. From the front rooms, she could see the tops of the trees in Hyde Park. Once she climbed onto the ledge and stood there for a moment, above the traffic and the fumes, mesmerized by the movement of the trees and the clouds in the sky.
